Full Text
WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) 3267 OF 2004
LIMITED ..... Petitioner
Through: Ms. Jhuma Bose, Adv.
Through: Mr. Sanjay Ghose, Adv.
JUDGMENT
1. Whether reporters of local papers may be allowed to see the judgment? YES
2. To be referred to the Reporter or not? YES
3. Whether the judgment should be reported in the Digest? YES
JUDGMENT
SIDDHARTH MRIDUL, J.
1. The present petition is directed against the order dated 7th March, 2003 and the subsequent award dated 28th March, 2003 passed by the Presiding Officer, Labour Court-I, Karkardooma Courts, Delhi in ID No.319 of 1985 directing the petitioner herein to reinstate the respondent no.1 with back wages.
2. The factual matrix, as is relevant for the adjudication of the present petition is as follows: (a) S. Ganesh Prasad, respondent no.1 herein, was employed with the management as Packer for more than one year 2008:DHC:2622 preceding the date of his illegal termination on 18th October, 1983. (b) Ganesh Prasad is stated to have written several letters to the management seeking reinstatement but to no avail. Eventually he reported the matter to the Labour Office. However, despite intervention by the Labour Inspector the management refused to take the workman back on duty on 20th January, 1984. Demand notice and conciliation proceedings which ensued thereafter failed to yield any result and the dispute with regard to termination of Ganesh Prasad was referred to the Industrial Adjudicator.
(c) The management, inter alia, contested the claim of
Ganesh Prasad and stated that during the period of employment Ganesh Prasad was reported to have committed on 18th October, 1983, theft of one packet of single weight glossy special paper. The management charge sheeted Ganesh Prasad on 2nd November, 1983 as per Standing Order relating to theft, fraud and dishonesty in connection with the management’s property and also placed the latter under suspension w.e.f. 2nd November,
1983.
(d) Since the explanation dated 14th November, 1983 in reply to the charge sheet was found not satisfactory, an enquiry was ordered on 16th November, 1983. (e) S. Ganesh Prasad, at the enquiry held on 24th November, 1983 denied the charges of misconduct. (f) On behalf of the management it was stated that though S. Ganesh Prasad participated in the enquiry initially, he absented himself later and the Enquiry Officer proceeded to conduct the enquiry ex-parte. (g) S. Ganesh Prasad was found guilty of the charges framed against him on the basis of the documents available and was terminated from his services by the management. (h) The Industrial Adjudicator proceeded to frame the following issues:
1. Whether the workman was appointed on probation as alleged? If so its effect?
2. What were his last drawn wages.
3. Whether the termination of services of Sh. Ganesh Prasad is legal and justified and if not to what relief is he entitled and what directions are necessary in this respect.
(i) Subsequently an additional issue no.3A as under was framed on the pleadings of the parties: “Whether the management conducted unfair and improper enquiry against the workman”. (j) The Industrial Adjudicator while going through the proceedings of the enquiry duly considered the order passed by the Enquiry Officer as follows: “Sh. Ganesh Prasad brought Mr. Bhatia whom he had mentioned in his letters. Mr. Bhatia was informed that he can not be permitted to assist the worker. Hence, the enquiry which was scheduled to take place could be taken up only at 11AM on 26th November, 1983. Sh. Ganesh Prasad left the enquiry hall and did not come even after an hour the enquiry is held exparte and based on the documents in support of the charge of misconduct leveled against the worker charged, copies of which documents, were also given to the worker, he is held guilty of the charge of misconducts framed against him in the letter dated 2.11.1983. (k) Vide order dated 7th March, 2003, the Industrial Adjudicator came to a conclusion that the enquiry proceedings held by the Enquiry Officer besides being perverse, were arrived at in haste without affording a fair opportunity to the workman. Vide the order dated 7th March, 2003 the Industrial Adjudicator vitiated the enquiry, and since it had not been pleaded on behalf of the management to lead evidence before the Industrial Adjudicator, proceeded to hear the merits to the reference, with a direction to the parties to produce evidence by way of affidavit on the other issues framed.
(l) Vide the impugned order dated 28th March, 2003 the
Industrial Adjudicator held that, the management had failed to discharge the onus to prove that the workman was appointed on probation. The claimant on the other hand had been able to establish that his last drawn wages were Rs.750/- per month as his testimony on this issue went uncontroverted during his cross-examination by the management. The termination of services of the claimant was found illegal and unjustified, and the management was directed to reinstate the workman with continuity of service. But, finding that it was the workman who had delayed the adjudication of the reference and its disposal for a period of two years, the payment of back wages was limited to the extent of 50% by the Industrial Adjudicator.
3. Ms. Jhuma Bose, advocate appearing on behalf of the management firstly submitted that S. Ganesh Prasad was not entitled to any relief, inasmuch as, he had delayed the proceedings before the Labour Court for a period of more than two years thereby causing serious prejudice to the management and that the managementcompany had been declared as a sick industrial company by the Board for Industrial and Financial Reconstruction(BIFR) in the meantime. It was further urged that it was only on account of the delay caused by the workman that the management failed to put forth their defence crucial stages, during of hearing before the Industrial Adjudicator, for reason of sickness as aforesaid. Counsel also urged that the Labour Court had failed to appreciate that despite the workman not cooperating with the enquiry proceedings the management had conducted a fair enquiry and imposed the penalty of dismissal from service after due consideration of the grave and serious misconduct on the part of Ganesh Prasad.
4. Per contra it was urged by Mr. Sanjay Ghose, advocate on behalf of S. Ganesh Prasad that the management had failed to (a) produce the witnesses to the purported confession made by the workman in respect of the alleged misconduct, (b) failed to seek an opportunity to lead evidence before the Industrial Adjudicator and consequently they could not by way of the present petition seek readjudication or reappreciation of the facts as found by the Industrial Adjudicator. He further urged that vide the finding in the impugned award in respect of the finding of delay having been caused by the workman, the Industrial Adjudicator had consequently directed reinstatement with continuity of service, but subject to only 50% back wages, and, therefore, the impugned award was sustainable as being just and equitable.
5. The scope of judicial review in a proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is no longer res integra. This Court under the provisions of Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot undertake the exercise of liberally reappreciating the evidence and drawing conclusions of its own on pure questions of fact. The findings of fact recorded by a fact-finding authority duly constituted for the purpose cannot be interfered with as long as they are based upon some material relevant for the purpose or even on the ground that there is yet another view which can reasonably and possibly be taken.
6. In the present case the findings of the Industrial Adjudicator are based on the appreciation of evidence produced before it. I am of the view that the findings cannot be said to be based on no evidence at all, so as to, warrant a re-appreciation of evidence, by this Court. The limitations on the jurisdiction of this Court are well settled. A writ in the nature of certiorari may be issued only if the finding of the Industrial Adjudicator suffers from an error or jurisdiction or from a breach of principles of natural justice or is vitiated by a manifest or apparent error of law. No such issue has been urged or established in the instant case on behalf of the management. The Court will not countenance the picking of holes here and there in the award on trivial points and attempting thereby to frustrate the entire adjudication process before the Industrial Adjudicator on hypertechnical grounds as is being sought to be done by the management in the present case.
7. For the foregoing reasons, I find no merit in the submissions made on behalf of the petitioner. The findings of the Industrial Adjudicator are based on material constituting ample basis for the findings recorded and the reasonable findings are unexceptionable. The Award does not suffer from any infirmity so as to warrant interference by this Court. As a result the writ petition fails and is accordingly dismissed, but, with no order as to costs.