The Vaish Coop Adarsh Bank Ltd. v. Pushpa Builder Ltd. & Ors.

Delhi High Court · 10 Sep 2008 · 2008:DHC:2617
Sanjiv Khanna
Execution Petition No. 180/1997
2008:DHC:2617
civil appeal_allowed Significant

AI Summary

The Delhi High Court held that post-1995 interest on a decree linked to RBI directives must follow prevailing RBI rates or contractual rates, disallowing compounding beyond the agreed rate.

Full Text
Translation output
Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 1 18.
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
EX.P. 180/1997
THE VAISH COOP ADARSH BANK LTD. ... Decree Holder
Through Mr. Lalit Gupta, Advocate.
VERSUS
PUSHPA BUILDER LTD. & ORS. .....
JUDGMENT
Debtors
Through Ms. Rekha Palli & Mr. Puran Singh, Advocates for the judgment debtor No. 1.
Mr. Pradeep Gaur, Advocate for the objectors-
Mr. Darshan Singh, Mrs. Anita Jain, Mr. T.D.
Taneja & Mr. T. MIthal-G.P.A. of Capt.
Hemant Juneja.
Mr. P.A.S. Rao, Advocate for the objector-M/s
K.C. Software (P) Ltd. in E.A. No. 580/2002.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJIV KHANNA O R D E R 10.09.2008

1. Learned counsel for the judgment debtor has handed over a demand draft of Rs.15,00,000/- to the learned counsel for the decree holder. The same has been accepted by the learned counsel for the decree holder without prejudice to the rights and contentions of his client.

2. The present execution petition has been filed by the Vaish Cooperative Adarsh Bank Limited, the decree holder for execution of the final decree dated 20th August, 1996. Earlier on the basis of an 2008:DHC:2617 Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 2 application under Order XXIII, Rules 1 and 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 being I.A. No. 1798/1992, a preliminary decree for recovery of Rs.23,37,177/- as on 31st December, 1991 along with costs of Rs.22,688.75 and future interest @ 23% per annum from 1st January, 1992 was passed. It was expressly stated in the preliminary decree that the compromise application I.A. No. 1798/199 marked Ex. C-1 shall form part of the decree. It was further directed that in case of failure/default of the judgment debtor to pay three consecutive installments, the decree holder shall be entitled to execute the decree by sale of the mortgaged property, viz. plot No. M-5, Greater Kailash II, New Delhi along with the building erected thereon.

3. The dispute between the parties pertains to interpretation of the decree as well as I.A. No. 1798/1992, Ex. C-1 and terms and conditions on which the parties had compromised and settled the matter. The terms of the compromise as recorded in I.A. NO. 1798/1992, and which forms part of the decree, read as under:-

“2. That the plaintiff and defendant Nos. 1 and 2 have arrived at a compromise and have settled the matter amicably out of court. It has been agreed between the plaintiff and defendants Nos. 1 and 2, as follows:-
(i) That the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 admit that as on 31 December, 1991 a sum of
Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 3 Rs.23,37,177/- is due and payable by the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 to the plaintiff in the said loan account No. FS/95/II inclusive of interest due till 31.12.1991.
(ii) That besides the above said amount, costs of the present suit have been agreed to be paid by the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 to the extent of Rs.22,688.75 inclusive of court fee, counsel’s fee and other expenses to the plaintiff. That the aforesaid amount of Rs.23,37,177/- shall carry future interest w.e.f. 01.01.1992 as per latest direction of the Reserve Bank of India from time to time and Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 1973, which at present is 23% p.a. (i.e. 20% minimum as per R.B.I. directives in force and 3% p.a. additional interest as per Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 1973) to be calculated on day to day basis and chargeable with quarterly rests, subject to change/s as per those directives.
(iii) That in view of the above admission, the plaintiff has acceded to the request of the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 to allow the defendants 1 and 2 to make the payment of the above said amounts in monthly instalments of Rs.50,000/- each payable latest by 15th of every succeeding month and first instalment payable latest by 15th of January, 1992 for which defendant No. 1 has already given a cheque to the plaintiff at the time of signing this application which the plaintiff acknowledges to have received. Out of the amounts so paid every month, firstly it will be adjusted towards interest and surplus, if any, will be adjusted towards principal and so on and so forth. It has further been agreed that after payment of 40 instalments as above mentioned whatsoever balance is remaining due, the same shall be payable by the defendants Nos. 1 and 2 in the next 8 months and the whole of the loan amount inclusive of Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 4 interest and costs shall be paid latest by the end of 48 months i.e. 31.12.1995.
(iv) That the plaintiff will not be entitled to file execution or make an application for sale of the mortgaged property if defendants Nos. 1 and 2 pay the instalments regularly as above mentioned and will only be entitled to execute the Decree and apply for sale of the mortgaged property if defendants Nos. 1 and 2 make default in payment of three consecutive instalments and only in that eventuality the mortgaged property shall be liable to be sold. That the plaintiff will abandon its suit against defendant No. 3 however this compromise will not in any way impair the liability of defendant No. 2 as surety.
(v) In case the proceeds of the sale of the mortgaged property fall short of the decreetal amount, the balance can be recovered from the other assets of defendants Nos. 1 and 2.”

4. A reading of the above terms show that there was no dispute between the parties to the principal amount due and payable by the judgment debtors as on 31st December, 1991 i.e. Rs.23,37,177/-. The principal amount was inclusive of interest payable till 31st December, 1991. There is also no dispute that the judgment debtors were liable to pay Rs.22,688.75 towards Court fees, counsel’s fees and other expenses.

5. Clause 2(ii) stipulates that the judgment debtors shall pay future interest on Rs.23,37,177/- with effect from 1st January, 1992 as per the latest directions of the Reserve Bank of India from time to time Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 5 and Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 1973. It is admitted case of the parties that no directions have been issued and the Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 1973 do not prescribe interest rate except that under the Rules the judgment debtor is liable to pay additional interest @ 3% per annum. The question pertains to rate of interest payable by the judgment debtors to the decree holder on Rs.23,37,177/- with effect from 1st January, 1992 in terms of the directions issued by the Reserve Bank of India from time to time. The dispute is about the rate of interest and whether it can be compounded.

6. It is admitted case of the parties that as per Reserve Bank of India directive at the time when the decree was passed, interest was payable @ 23% per annum i.e. 20% as per Reserve Bank of India directive in force and 3% additional interest as per Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 1973. Further interest was to be calculated on dayto-day basis but chargeable with quarterly rests. The said directive continued to be in force till 20th June, 1995, though interest rates were reduced. Accordingly, in terms of the decree, the judgment debtor will be liable to pay interest in terms of the directives, on dayto-day basis but chargeable with quarterly rests for the period between 1st January, 1992 till 20th June, 1995. Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 6

7. By circular dated 20th June, 1995, Reserve Bank of India reviewed the existing lending rate structure for primary cooperative banks and they were given freedom to determine their lending rates subject to the prescription that the minimum lending rates shall be 13% per annum. Subsequently, by another circular dated 2nd March, 2002, Reserve Bank of India reduced the minimum lending rate to 12% per annum. By another circular dated 29th April, 2002, cooperative banks were given complete freedom to fix lending rates and Reserve Bank of India withdrew all directions with regard to lending rates. These facts have been confirmed by the Reserve Bank of India in their affidavit filed on 24th January, 2007 pursuant to directions given by this Court.

8. Learned counsel for the decree holder submits that the judgment debtors are liable to pay interest @ 20% per annum in spite of the circulars dated 20th June, 1995 and thereafter, in terms of the said decree. Interest it is stated has to be paid as per Reserve Bank of India directive in force before circular dated 20th June, 1995. On the other hand, it is the contention of the judgment debtors that they should be charged minimum lending rates prescribed in the circulars of the Reserve Bank of India. Another question, which arises for consideration is whether the decree holder is entitled to compound Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 7 interest.

14,545 characters total

9. The decree holder has filed a computation chart, which shows that they have calculated interest @ 22% per annum from 1st March, 1992 to 8th October, 1992 and gradually reduced the same to 18% per annum till 30th June, 1995. However, with effect from 1st July, 1995 they have charged interest @ 20% per annum. For the purpose of the present decree, interest charged by the decree holder with quarterly rests at different rates as shown in the chart from 1st January, 1992 till 30th June, 1995 is treated as correct. This is also acceptable to the counsel for the judgment debtor Nos. 1 and 2.

10. As already stated above, with effect from 1st July, 1995, Reserve Bank of India directions had only prescribed minimum rate of interest, which too was 13% per annum. Minimum rate of interest was substantially lower than the contractual rate of interest of 15% per annum, when loan agreement was executed between the parties. Learned counsel for the decree holder has not been able to justify claim of interest @20% per annum on the basis of the Reserve Bank of India directive dated 20th June, 1995. The use of the words “from time to time” in Ex. C-1, the compromise application with reference to the Reserve Bank of India directions shows that interest rate was not static but fluctuating or floating and dependent upon Reserve Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 8 Bank of India directions. The decree holder was bound to follow Reserve Bank of India directions on interest rates. In terms of the directions of Reserve Bank of India, the decree holder had themselves reduced rate of interest for the period after the decree till June, 1995, which also establishes that the interest rate was to be fluctuating or floating. However, after June, 1995, Reserve Bank of India withdrew directions fixing specific interest rates and banks were given liberty to fix interest rates in contracts, subject to the minimum interest rate fixed by the Reserve Bank of India. The contractual rate fixed by the parties in the agreement is applicable, if it is more than the minimum interest rate fixed by the Reserve Bank of India. Looking at the decree passed in the present case, I feel that the contractual rate of interest, which is 15% per annum, is due and payable by the judgment debtors to the decree holder after 1st July,

1995. In addition, the judgment debtor will be also liable to pay 3% additional interest as prescribed under the Delhi Cooperative Societies Rules, 1973. The effective rate of interest, therefore, will be 18% per annum with effect from 1st July, 1995 onwards. The said rate of interest will continue till full payment is made. Payments made will be adjusted and set off as per para 2 (iii) of I.A. No. 1798/1992.

11. On the question whether the interest can be compounded, I find Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 9 that the contractual terms did not provide for compounding of interest. Only simple interest was payable to the decree holder by the judgment debtors.

12. Learned counsel for the decree holder, however, relies upon circulars dated 30th March, 2002 and 26th August, 2002 issued by the Reserve Bank of India. Circular dated 30th March, 2002 stipulates that with effect from 1st April, 2002, banks shall move over to charging of interest on loans/advances at monthly rests, except in cases of agricultural advances. In clause (iv) it is also stated that interest on monthly rests will apply to new term loans and other loans for longer/fixed periods. This circular, however, was superseded and followed by another circular dated 26th August, 2002. By this circular dated 26th August, 2002 banks were given option to compound interest on monthly rests with effect from 1st April, 2002, 1st July, 2002 or 1st April, 2003. In addition, in paragraph 2(ii), it was stipulated as under:- “2.(ii) With effect from quarter beginning July 1, 2002, banks should ensure that the effective rate does not go up merely on account of the switchover to the system of charging /compounding interest at monthly rests and increase the burden on the borrowers. Illustratively: Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 10 If a bank is charging in a borrower’s account an interest rate of 12 percent with quarterly rests, the effective rate is 12.55 percent. If the bank charges in the same account an interest rate of 12 percent at monthly rests, the effective rate comes to 12.68 percent. Banks should, therefore, adjust the interest rate charged to the borrower in such a way that the effective interest rate to the borrower does not exceed 12.55 percent as hitherto. Thus, in the above example, banks should charge interest at 11.88 percent (and not 12 percent). If this is done, the effective rate, even after compounding at monthly rests, will be 12.55 percent. ”

13. Thus, the effective rate of interest fixed in the contract would remain unchanged in spite of switchover and charging of interest on monthly rests. There was to be no increase of burden on the borrowers. The said circular did not provide and stipulate that the banks can compound interest on monthly rests so as to exceed the contractual rate of interest already fixed between the parties. The contractual rate of interest shall be decreased on account of switchover to system of charging compound interest on monthly rests in view of the condition that the total interest burden on the borrowers should not exceed the contractual rate so fixed. In these circumstances, I do not think that the decree holder bank is entitled to claim interest over and above 18% per annum even with effect from 1st April, 2002, 1st July, 2002 or 1st April, 2003 or compound the same Execution Petition No. 180/1997 Page 11 so as to exceed 18% rate of interest. Thus, the judgment debtors will be liable to pay interest @18% per annum with effect from 1st July, 1995 onwards and even if compounding is done for the period after 1st April, 2002, it will be in terms of the Circular dated 26th August, 2002 and the effective rate of interest will not exceed 18% p.a. The decree holder will make calculation in terms of this order. Copy of the calculation sheet will be furnished to the judgment debtors within a period of fifteen days and copy thereof will be given to the counsel for the judgment debtors, who assures this Court that balance amount, if any, shall be paid within four weeks. List this matter again on 25th November, 2008.

SANJIV KHANNA, J. SEPTEMBER 10, 2008 VKR/P