Full Text
LA.APP.24/2009
RAJ SINGH & ORS.
Through:
Appellant UOI & ANR.
Through:
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
CHOTU & ANR.
Through:
Appellants UOI & ANR.
Through:
SHRI BRAHMA
Through:
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
Appellant
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
Page 1 of8 2011:DHC:12704
RISHI RAJ RANA& ANR.
Through:
Appellants UOI & ANR.
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
M.P.GUPTA
Through:
Appellant
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
RAGHUBIR SINGH
Through:
Appellant UOI & ANR.
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
BHULLAN @ BHULE & ANR.
Through:
Appellants Page2of8 2011:DHC:12704
UOI & ANR.
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
M.P.GUPTA & SONS
Through:
.Appellants
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar,Advocate, Mr.Rannesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
MEHAR SINGH & ORS.
Through:
.Appellants
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
SANJEEV TUSHIR
Through:
.Appellants Page3of8 2011:DHC:12704 s
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray,Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar,Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
JAI NARAYAN & ORS
Through:
.Appellants
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar,Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
LAKHI RAM
Through:
.Appellant
Through:
GURDEV SINGH
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar,Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
.Appellant Page4of8 2011:DHC:12704
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar,Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
RAJ SINGH (D)THRU LRS
Through:
.Appellants
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
NISHA GUPTA
Through:
.Appellant
Through:
Respondents Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
RATTAN SINGH
Through:
Appellant Mr.Kuldeep Balhara, Advocate and Mr.Mukesh Gupta, Advocate.
Page5of8 2011:DHC:12704
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.indrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
CHARAN SINGH & ORS. Appellants
Through: Mr.Kuldeep Baihara, Advocate and Mr.Mukesh Gupta, Advocate.
UOI & ORS.
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.indrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
RAGHUBIR SINGH
Through:
Appellant Mr.Kuldeep Balhara, Advocate and Mr.Mukesh Gupta, Advocate.
UOI Si ORS.
Through:
ANGOORI Si ORS.
Through:
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.indrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for DDA.
Appellants Mr.Kuldeep Balhara, Advocate and Mr.Mukesh Gupta, Advocate.
Page6of8 2011:DHC:12704
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for PDA.
HEM CHANDERSHARMA DECD.
THR LRs Appellant
Through: Mr.Kuldeep Balhara, Advocate and Mr.Mukesh Gupta, Advocate.
Through: Mr.Sanjay Poddar, Advocate, Mr.Ramesh Ray, Advocate and
Mr.Ashish Tanwar, Advocate for UOI.
Ms.lndrani Ghosh and Ms.Shobhna Takiar, Advocate for PDA.
02.06.2011
ORDER
1. The instant appeals pertain to lands situated in the revenue estate of village Ghevra, and the notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act 1894 with which 1 am concerned was issued on 6.2.2003.
2. The Reference Court has assessed the compensation @ ?1,18,367/- besides other statutory benefits as per the Land Acquisition Act 1894.
3. Deciding a batch of appeals lead matter being LA.APP Page 7of[8] 2011:DHC:12704 No.489/2008 Chiranii La! Vs. UP! & Anr. today itself, with reference to a decision dated 19.12.2008 passed by a Division Bench deciding LA.APP.No.193/2006 Pratao Singh (through LRs) Vs. UO!& Ors. I have determined the fair market value of the lands in village Ghevra at ^4,03,425/- per bigha as of 6.2.2003.
4. The appeals stand disposed of decreeing the same enhancing the compensation payable to the appellants @^4,03,425/- per bigha; additionally decreed that the appellants would be entitled to the statutory benefits as per the Land Acquisition Act 1894 including the decision of the Supreme Court reported as 93(2001)DLT 569 Sunder Vs. Union ofIndia.
5. The appellants would also be entitled to proportionate costs.
6. Pending applications, if any, in the appeals stand disposed of in terms ofthe prayer made in the application. ^■^*1 PRADEEP NANDRAJOG,J. June 2, 2011 dk Page 8 of[8]