Full Text
Translation output
$-58 HIGH COURT OF DELHI
LA.APP.367/2010
UNION OF INDIA Appellant
Through: Ms.Deepika, Advocate
LA.APP.367/2010
UNION OF INDIA Appellant
Through: Ms.Deepika, Advocate
VERSUS
MEENAKSHI & ANR. Respondents
Through: Mr.L.B.Rai, Advocate for R-1 Mr.B.B.Sharma, Advocate for DDA
Through: Mr.L.B.Rai, Advocate for R-1 Mr.B.B.Sharma, Advocate for DDA
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP NANDRAJOG
08.07.2011 For orders, see LA.APP.No. 784/2005.
PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.
JULY 08, 2011 mm 2011:DHC:13616 c . . •• . .... . .... : •' ......
. . ... ..
•.••H.
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
. .. . . . .. . . . . .. . .., : . . f'o
Date pfDeCL5/QI2 8thJuIV, 2Qj AAPP784/200 . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . .:
• .
JAMNA
Appellant
Through: Mr.L.B.RaI, Advocate, . . i •: . .: . 1•
Mr I S Dahiya, Advocate, Mr 0 S Lakra, Advocate, Mr K Sunil, Advocate, '
Mr Anuj Bhandafl, Advocate Mr Shadam Farashat, Advocate
..I
••• . : . .... '.... .: . . i . . ....,.. NV. . :• • . . . ., . . ' ..
08.07.2011 For orders, see LA.APP.No. 784/2005.
PRADEEP NANDRAJOG, J.
JULY 08, 2011 mm 2011:DHC:13616 c . . •• . .... . .... : •' ......
. . ... ..
•.••H.
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
. .. . . . .. . . . . .. . .., : . . f'o
Date pfDeCL5/QI2 8thJuIV, 2Qj AAPP784/200 . . .. . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. . .:
• .
JAMNA
Appellant
Through: Mr.L.B.RaI, Advocate, . . i •: . .: . 1•
Mr I S Dahiya, Advocate, Mr 0 S Lakra, Advocate, Mr K Sunil, Advocate, '
Mr Anuj Bhandafl, Advocate Mr Shadam Farashat, Advocate
..I
••• . : . .... '.... .: . . i . . ....,.. NV. . :• • . . . ., . . ' ..
VERSUS
• . .., . . ... .. . . .. . . :, .. .: .
& ORS Respondents ) Through Mr Sanjay Poddar, Standing a
Counsel (LA), GNCT Delhi with
•
Ms Deepika, Mr Sachin Nawafli and Mr. Siddharth Panda Advocates
Mr.Ajay.Vermal Ms Kanika Agnihotfl, Mr Kunal Sharma, Mr Sumer Sethi, Mr B B Sharma, Ms Shobhna Takiar and Arun
Mr Birbal, Advocates for, DDA AND . .
& ORS Respondents ) Through Mr Sanjay Poddar, Standing a
Counsel (LA), GNCT Delhi with
•
Ms Deepika, Mr Sachin Nawafli and Mr. Siddharth Panda Advocates
Mr.Ajay.Vermal Ms Kanika Agnihotfl, Mr Kunal Sharma, Mr Sumer Sethi, Mr B B Sharma, Ms Shobhna Takiar and Arun
Mr Birbal, Advocates for, DDA AND . .
LAAPP 879/2005, LAAPP 880-881/2005, LAAPP
121/2006, 143/2007 (Relating to NotificatiOn u/s 4 dated
25 02 1997 & Award No 2/1999-2000, Village Mundka)
$ AND
121/2006, 143/2007 (Relating to NotificatiOn u/s 4 dated
25 02 1997 & Award No 2/1999-2000, Village Mundka)
$ AND
LAAPP 583/2009, LAAPP 603/20091 LAAPP 604/2009, LA APP 606/2009, LA APP 610/2009, 74/2010, LA APP 78/2010, wwl
LA APP 784/2005 & connected p
. ..
:. •:•.
I i
. ..
:. •:•.
I i
LAAPP 79/2010, LAAPP 121/2010, LAAPP 12242010 1 LAAPP
125/2010, LAAPP 164/2010, LAAPP 185/2010, LAAPP I
186/2010, LA APP 200/2010, LAAPP 238/2010, LAAPP
239/2010, LA APP 243/2010, LA APP 244/2010, LA APP
245/2010, LAAPP 247/2010, LAAPP 251/2010, LAAPP
252/2010, LAAPP 266/2010, LAAPP 267/2010, LAAPP
273/2010, LAAPP 274/2010, LAAPP 275/2010, LAAPP
312/2010, LAAPP 324/2010, L.A.APP 326/2010, LAAPP
• . , 327/2010 LA.APP. 32912010,' LA.APP. 330/2010, LA.APP
31/2010, LA.APP. 332/2010, LA.APP; 333 •' ith CM PL..
Nb. 5524/2011, LA.APP; 335/2010 LA.APP. '367/2010, LAPP..
368/2010, LA APP 369/2010, LAA APPL No 20099/2010, LAAPP 374/2010, LAAPP 375/2010, LAAPP
37712010, LAAPP 379/2010, LAAPP 423/2010, LAAPP
452/2010, LAAPP 461/2010, LAAPP 472/2010, LA.APP.'!
694/2010, LA.APR 696/2010 M APPLJNo. 6340/201L LA.APP. .....697/2010, 'LA.APP. 6g8/2010:&.. CM APPL; 1734/2011 1 LA.APP.
706/2010 & CM APPL 17215/2010, LA APP 707/2010, LA APP
708/2010, LA.APP. 7.09/2010, LkAPP. 710/2010.wi.th d 'APPL. .
No 2568/2011, LA APP 713/2010 with CM APPL No 7473/2010, LA APP 715/2010, LAAPP 717/2010, LA APP 719/2010, AAPP
766/2010, LAAPP 796/2010, LAAPP 79712010, LAAPP
798/2010, LAAPP 799/2010, LAAPP 818/2O0, LAAPP
819/2010, LA APP 829/2010, LA APP 831/2010 & CM APPL
955/2011, LAAPP 832/2010, LAAPP 83/2010 & CM APPL
6392/2011, LAAPP 834/2010, LAAPP 842/2010, LAAPP
871/2010, LAAPP 874/20101 LAAPP 875/20,10, LAAPP
876/2010, LAAPP 877/2010, LAAPP 878/2010, LAAPP
879/2010, LA APP 880/2010, LA APP 881/2010 & CM
125/2010, LAAPP 164/2010, LAAPP 185/2010, LAAPP I
186/2010, LA APP 200/2010, LAAPP 238/2010, LAAPP
239/2010, LA APP 243/2010, LA APP 244/2010, LA APP
245/2010, LAAPP 247/2010, LAAPP 251/2010, LAAPP
252/2010, LAAPP 266/2010, LAAPP 267/2010, LAAPP
273/2010, LAAPP 274/2010, LAAPP 275/2010, LAAPP
312/2010, LAAPP 324/2010, L.A.APP 326/2010, LAAPP
• . , 327/2010 LA.APP. 32912010,' LA.APP. 330/2010, LA.APP
31/2010, LA.APP. 332/2010, LA.APP; 333 •' ith CM PL..
Nb. 5524/2011, LA.APP; 335/2010 LA.APP. '367/2010, LAPP..
368/2010, LA APP 369/2010, LAA APPL No 20099/2010, LAAPP 374/2010, LAAPP 375/2010, LAAPP
37712010, LAAPP 379/2010, LAAPP 423/2010, LAAPP
452/2010, LAAPP 461/2010, LAAPP 472/2010, LA.APP.'!
694/2010, LA.APR 696/2010 M APPLJNo. 6340/201L LA.APP. .....697/2010, 'LA.APP. 6g8/2010:&.. CM APPL; 1734/2011 1 LA.APP.
706/2010 & CM APPL 17215/2010, LA APP 707/2010, LA APP
708/2010, LA.APP. 7.09/2010, LkAPP. 710/2010.wi.th d 'APPL. .
No 2568/2011, LA APP 713/2010 with CM APPL No 7473/2010, LA APP 715/2010, LAAPP 717/2010, LA APP 719/2010, AAPP
766/2010, LAAPP 796/2010, LAAPP 79712010, LAAPP
798/2010, LAAPP 799/2010, LAAPP 818/2O0, LAAPP
819/2010, LA APP 829/2010, LA APP 831/2010 & CM APPL
955/2011, LAAPP 832/2010, LAAPP 83/2010 & CM APPL
6392/2011, LAAPP 834/2010, LAAPP 842/2010, LAAPP
871/2010, LAAPP 874/20101 LAAPP 875/20,10, LAAPP
876/2010, LAAPP 877/2010, LAAPP 878/2010, LAAPP
879/2010, LA APP 880/2010, LA APP 881/2010 & CM
APPL6505/2011, LAAPP 882/2010, LAAPP 883/2010, LAAPP
884/2010, . LA.APP. 886/2010, LA.APP.; 888/2010 LA:APP. .
884/2010, . LA.APP. 886/2010, LA.APP.; 888/2010 LA:APP. .
S .. 889/2010 & CM APPL2249/2011, LAAPP 890/2010, LAAPP
893/2010 & CM APPL 6750/2011, LA APP 894/2010 & CM
No23353/2010, LAAPP 895/2010, LAAPP 896/2d1, LAAPP
897/2010 & CM APPL728/2011, LAAPP 903/2010, LAAPP
893/2010 & CM APPL 6750/2011, LA APP 894/2010 & CM
No23353/2010, LAAPP 895/2010, LAAPP 896/2d1, LAAPP
897/2010 & CM APPL728/2011, LAAPP 903/2010, LAAPP
LAAPP784/2005&connected PageZofl9
907/2010, LAAPP 938/2010, LAAPP 93912010, L.APP
10.34/2010 & CM APPL 3086/2011, LA APP 1040/2010 & CM
907/2010, LAAPP 938/2010, LAAPP 93912010, L.APP
10.34/2010 & CM APPL 3086/2011, LA APP 1040/2010 & CM
APPL 5673/2011, LAAPP 1041/2010, LAAPP 1043/20101
LA APP 104/2010, LA APP 1046/2010, LA APP 104842010, 1
LAAPP 1049/2010, LAAPP 1050/2010, LAAPP 1056/2010, LA.APP. 1060/2010, )LAAPP. 1061/2010, LA.AP. . 1071-10.10, LA'.APP 125/2.011, LA.APP. 126/2011, LA.APP. .25/2011 . .
(Relating to Notification u/s 4 dated 21 03 03 & Award
No 3/2005-06, Village-Mundka)
(Relating to Notification u/s 4 dated 21 03 03 & Award
No 3/2005-06, Village-Mundka)
AND
LA APP 600/2009 1 LA APP 605/2009, LA APP 615/20091
:LA.APP. 310/2010, LA.APP. 325/2010, .LA.APP. 37.6/2010, LAAPP.
383/2010, LA.APP. 384/2010, LAAPP; 385/2010, LA.APP.
473/2010, LA.APP. 492/2010, LAAPP.. 586/2010, LA.APP.
690/2010, LAAPP 591/2010, LAAPP 638/2010, LAAPP
692/2010, LAAPP 711/2010, LAAPP 716/2010, LAAPP
763/2010, LAAPP 872/2010, LAAPP 873/2010, LAAPP
885/2010, LAAPP 887/2010, LAAPP 891/2010, LAAPP
892/2010, LAAPP 898/2010, LAAPP 906/2010 & CJV1 APPL
No.4443/2010, LA.APP. 937/2010 & CM APPL. 23299/2010, LA:APP. 1042/2010, LA.APP. 1047/201.0.. . ,. . . ••.•
(Relating to Notification u/s 4 dated 21 03 2003 & Award
No 1/2005-06, Village-Mundka)
AND
:LA.APP. 310/2010, LA.APP. 325/2010, .LA.APP. 37.6/2010, LAAPP.
383/2010, LA.APP. 384/2010, LAAPP; 385/2010, LA.APP.
473/2010, LA.APP. 492/2010, LAAPP.. 586/2010, LA.APP.
690/2010, LAAPP 591/2010, LAAPP 638/2010, LAAPP
692/2010, LAAPP 711/2010, LAAPP 716/2010, LAAPP
763/2010, LAAPP 872/2010, LAAPP 873/2010, LAAPP
885/2010, LAAPP 887/2010, LAAPP 891/2010, LAAPP
892/2010, LAAPP 898/2010, LAAPP 906/2010 & CJV1 APPL
No.4443/2010, LA.APP. 937/2010 & CM APPL. 23299/2010, LA:APP. 1042/2010, LA.APP. 1047/201.0.. . ,. . . ••.•
(Relating to Notification u/s 4 dated 21 03 2003 & Award
No 1/2005-06, Village-Mundka)
AND
LAAPP 1003/2010, LAAPP 1017/20101 LAAPP 1019/2010, LA APP 1022/2010, LA APP 1023/2010, LA APP p 1044/2010, LAAPP 1051/2010, LAAPP 1053/2010, LAAPP 1054/2010 &
CM APPL No 5656/2011, LA APP 1055/2010, LAAPP
1057/2010, LA.APP. 1058/2010, LAAPP. 1059/2010, LA.APP.
1068/2010, LAAPP. 1069/2010,LA.APP. 124/2011, LA.APP., 127/2011, LA.APP: 128/2011, LA.APP. 259/2.011 . . . . •.
CM APPL No 5656/2011, LA APP 1055/2010, LAAPP
1057/2010, LA.APP. 1058/2010, LAAPP. 1059/2010, LA.APP.
1068/2010, LAAPP. 1069/2010,LA.APP. 124/2011, LA.APP., 127/2011, LA.APP: 128/2011, LA.APP. 259/2.011 . . . . •.
LA APP 784/2005 & connected
- r - 23,3,227 20 per acre, as oii 17 06 2Q0 Vr) FOr the land situated in Village Bkarwa t'he fau market value i s fixed at 425,641I- per bigha i e
2p,43,076 80 per acre, as on 24 0,9 2003 i) Appellants and cross-objectors who have succeedeq would also be entitled to solatium and inteest as per statute and as clarified in the decision reporited as
93(2001) DLT 569 Sunder vs 1.10/, for the compensation, paid originally and as enhanced by the Reference Court and finally on the sum enhanced by the present
- r - 23,3,227 20 per acre, as oii 17 06 2Q0 Vr) FOr the land situated in Village Bkarwa t'he fau market value i s fixed at 425,641I- per bigha i e
2p,43,076 80 per acre, as on 24 0,9 2003 i) Appellants and cross-objectors who have succeedeq would also be entitled to solatium and inteest as per statute and as clarified in the decision reporited as
93(2001) DLT 569 Sunder vs 1.10/, for the compensation, paid originally and as enhanced by the Reference Court and finally on the sum enhanced by the present
ORDER
and decree vii) The appellants and cross-objector who succeed would also be entitled to proportionate costs
All pending applications stand disposed of in terms of the prayers made therein
C
(PRAEEEP NANDRAJOG)
JUDGE
LYO8211 rnm - I i LAAPP784/200&connected ' Pagel9ofl9
All pending applications stand disposed of in terms of the prayers made therein
C
(PRAEEEP NANDRAJOG)
JUDGE
LYO8211 rnm - I i LAAPP784/200&connected ' Pagel9ofl9