Full Text
Translation output
CRL.M.A.1899/2007 and connected Crl.M.A.s in CRL.A.193/06 Page 1
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
HIGH COURT OF DELHI
Reserved on: 08.04.2013
Date of Decision: 22.05.2013 In the matter of
COURT ON ITS OWN MOTION In Re:
Crl.A.193/2006
STATE (GNCT OF DELHI) ….Appellant
COURT ON ITS OWN MOTION In Re:
Crl.A.193/2006
STATE (GNCT OF DELHI) ….Appellant
VERSUS
SIDHARTHA VASHISHT @ MANU SHARMA & ORS.
…..Respondents
…..Respondents
CRL.M.A.1898/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
STATE ……Appellant
STATE ……Appellant
VERSUS
SHYAN MUNSHI …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1899/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
SHIVDAS YADAV …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1900/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
ANDLEEP SEHGAL …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1901/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
MANOJ KUMAR …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1902/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
BALBIR SINGH …..Respondent
2013:DHC:2699-DB
2013:DHC:2699-DB
CRL.M.A.1899/2007 and connected Crl.M.A.s in CRL.A.193/06 Page 2
CRL.M.A.1904/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
TARSEM LAL THHAPAR …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1906/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
SHANKAR MUKHIA …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1908/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
CHANDER PARKASH CHABRA …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1909/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
ABHIJEET GHOSAL …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1910/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
BARUN SHAH …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1912/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
CHETAN NANDA …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1913/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
ASHOK DUTT …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1914/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
CRL.M.A.1899/2007 and connected Crl.M.A.s in CRL.A.193/06 Page 3
VERSUS
BALDEV SINGH …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1915/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
ISH DEEP SHARMA …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1916/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
ALI MOHAMMAD …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1917/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
KULVINDER SINGH …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1919/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
MANGAL SINGH …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1925/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
PREM SAGAR MANOCHA …..Respondent
CRL.M.A.1926/2007 IN CRL.A.193/2006
VERSUS
BABU LAL …..Respondent
Appearance: Sh. Pawan Sharma, Standing Counsel (Crl) with Sh. Harsh Prabhakar, Ms. Laxmi Chauhan, Sh.
Kushagra Arora, Advocates along with Inspector Keshav
Mathur, Crime Branch.
Sh. Sudarshan Rajan, Advocate, for Sh. Shyan Munshi.
Appearance: Sh. Pawan Sharma, Standing Counsel (Crl) with Sh. Harsh Prabhakar, Ms. Laxmi Chauhan, Sh.
Kushagra Arora, Advocates along with Inspector Keshav
Mathur, Crime Branch.
Sh. Sudarshan Rajan, Advocate, for Sh. Shyan Munshi.
CRL.M.A.1899/2007 and connected Crl.M.A.s in CRL.A.193/06 Page 4
Sh. Ritesh Khatri, Advocate, for Sh. Shivdas Yadav.
Sh. H.J.S. Ahluwalia, Advocate, for Sh. Tarsem Lal
Thhapar.
Sh. Amit Chadha, Advocate, for Sh. Barun Shah.
Ms. Savita Prabhakar, Advocate, for Sh. Prem Sagar
Manocha.
Sh. Ritesh Khatri, Advocate, for Sh. Shivdas Yadav.
Sh. H.J.S. Ahluwalia, Advocate, for Sh. Tarsem Lal
Thhapar.
Sh. Amit Chadha, Advocate, for Sh. Barun Shah.
Ms. Savita Prabhakar, Advocate, for Sh. Prem Sagar
Manocha.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G.P. MITTAL MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
For detailed judgement, the decision dated 22.05.2013 in Crl.
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G.P. MITTAL MR. JUSTICE S. RAVINDRA BHAT
For detailed judgement, the decision dated 22.05.2013 in Crl.
M.A. 1898/2007 in Crl.A. 193/2006 may be referred to.
S. RAVINDRA BHAT (JUDGE)
G.P. MITTAL (JUDGE)
MAY 22 2013
S. RAVINDRA BHAT (JUDGE)
G.P. MITTAL (JUDGE)
MAY 22 2013
JUDGMENT